Pets Best vs Trupanion Pet Insurance
The Pets Best vs Trupanion comparison turns on flexibility: adjustable coverage plus a 5% multi-pet discount, or a policy with fixed terms.
Terms for Pets Best and Trupanion plans
| Term |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Pets covered | Dogs and Cats | Dogs and Cats |
| Plan types | Accident and illness, Accident only, Wellness add-on | Accident and illness |
| Underwriter | American Pet Insurance Company, or Independence American Insurance Company, or Independence Pet Insurance Company, or MS Transverse Insurance Company | American Pet Insurance Company |
| Plans offered through | Pets Best Insurance Services, LLC | not published |
| Deductible options | $100 to $1,000 | $0 to $1,000, per condition |
| Deductible type | not published | Per condition (lifetime) |
| Reimbursement options | 70%, 80%, or 90% | 90% |
| Yearly limit choices | $5,000 or unlimited | Unlimited |
| Wait before accident cover | 3 days | 5 days |
| Illness waiting period | 14 days | 30 days |
| Youngest age to enroll | 7 weeks | From birth |
| Oldest age to enroll | No upper age limit | Before age 14 |
| Exam fee cover | Covered | No |
| Pre-existing conditions | Not covered | Not covered; only conditions the pet had before coverage began are excluded. Conditions showing up in the waiting periods are also treated as pre-existing. |
| Cured pre-existing conditions | Once a pet has been healed or cured for a period of 12 to 18 months, conditions such as broken bones, bruises, and kennel cough can be covered. | not published |
| Hereditary and congenital conditions | Covered | Covered |
| Dental illness | Limited | Covered |
| Behavioral conditions | Limited | Add-on |
| Alternative therapy | Add-on | Add-on |
| Wellness add-on | Covered | No |
| Multi-pet discount | 5% | false |
| Pays the vet directly | Covered | Covered |
| Claim payment speed | not published | Vets are paid directly, either within about five minutes of the invoice or, sometimes, within seconds of it. |
| Claims app | Pets Best offers a mobile app for Android and iOS, plus an online Customer Account. | At participating vets, bills go through VetDirect Pay; at any other vet, you get a mailed check or a direct deposit. |
| Where it is sold | All 50 states and Washington, D.C. | Available in all 50 states, in Washington, D.C., and in Puerto Rico (though some products and discounts may not reach everyone in every state) |
| Free-look period | 30 days, full refund if no claims paid | A full refund is offered for 30 days if you haven't had a claim paid, and that option isn't offered in New York. |
Source list: Frequently Asked Questions, What Are Waiting Periods | Pets Best, Resource Materials - Top Investor Questions | Trupanion, Inc., When does my coverage start? | Trupanion Pet Medical Insurance
Owners looking for exam fee coverage, routine care options, or protection for curable conditions healed for 12 to 18 months will find Pets Best a good match.
Seeking lifetime per-condition coverage and payment straight to participating vets within minutes? Trupanion suits owners located in 50 states, Puerto Rico, and Canada.
Pets Best vs Trupanion at a glance
Pets Best offers accident-and-illness and accident-only coverage plus a wellness add-on, while Trupanion has one accident-and-illness policy with no routine care. The insurer pays back a share of each covered vet bill; that share is called reimbursement, and it comes after your out-of-pocket share. The most a plan pays out for vet bills in a policy year is its annual limit. Adjustable rates apply to the $5,000 annual limit or unlimited payouts Pets Best offers, while Trupanion's unlimited payouts come at a rate that stays fixed.
Prices and deductibles
Your insurance plan starts paying only after you cover the deductible, the amount you pay on your own toward covered vet bills. The yearly deductible at Pets Best runs from $100 to $1,000. At Trupanion, the $0 to $1,000 deductible is charged per condition and stays that way for your pet's life. Looking at both plans, Pets Best lets you choose 70%, 80%, or 90% reimbursement with a capped or unlimited yearly maximum. Every Trupanion policy uses that top reimbursement rate, and your yearly or lifetime payouts are never capped.
A published Pets Best price example lists an Essential accident-and-illness plan at $37.68 monthly for a dog and $23.23 monthly for a cat. Quotes in that example are averaged across all states and Washington, D.C. The pets priced are neutered medium mixed-breed dogs, plus domestic shorthair cats, at 1 year old and at 6 years old. The example uses a $500 deductible, the highest reimbursement tier, and both $10,000 and unlimited limits. For a domestic short-haired cat, the Trupanion investor examples show a monthly quote of $20 in Boise, Idaho; an English Bulldog in Manhattan is quoted at $200.
Waiting times and age limits
The waiting period runs from your enrollment to the start of coverage, and conditions showing up during that span are excluded as pre-existing. Accident coverage at Pets Best begins after 3 days and illness coverage after 14 days, per its waiting periods; orthopedic and cruciate ligament problems require 6 months. Under Trupanion, accidents have a 5-day wait and illnesses a 30-day wait, per its waiting periods.
Pets Best opens enrollment at 7 weeks old for dogs and cats, and it places no age cap on senior pets. You can enroll puppies and kittens with Trupanion from birth (0 to 7 weeks old) until their 14th birthday, and coverage continues for life.
Which plan suits your pet
- Senior pets: Older dogs and cats past Trupanion's birthday cutoff suit Pets Best, since it places no limit on how old a pet can be.
- Very young puppies and kittens: Trupanion works for newborn pets, because you can enroll them as soon as they are born.
- Exam fees and routine care: Pets Best pays vet exam fees and sells a wellness add-on, while Trupanion covers neither exam fees nor preventive care.
- Hereditary and dental coverage: Hereditary conditions are covered by both insurers. Trupanion's dental illness coverage is full, while Pets Best puts limits on dental and behavioral care. Each company sells an alternative therapy add-on, and Trupanion includes behavioral care there as well.
- Paying the vet directly: Both insurers can pay vets directly. Trupanion's VetDirect Pay settles clinic bills within minutes or seconds of the invoice at participating vets. You can also file claims in the Pets Best mobile app, which runs on Android and iOS.
- Underwriting and refunds: American Pet Insurance Company underwrites both plans. Pets Best also relies on other underwriters and handles plans via Pets Best Insurance Services, LLC. Each company provides a full refund if you cancel without any claims paid during the first refund period (excluding Trupanion in New York).
Request plan pricing for your pet
We do not sell insurance, quote it, or bind it; your request goes to an insurance agency.